I have blogged quite a few posts about my buy in to ComfortDelgro (CDG) and why I thought it was a good buy. albeit being overvalued when I calculated the company’s actual intrinsic value.
Today, I would have to eat my words. And it is indeed because I chose to pay a premium for the stock in the beginning at $2.33.
As of the closing price since Friday, the price dropped further by 15.45% from my buying price to $1.975, and thus has significantly affected my portfolio returns, although overall returns still remain green. This is also the first time that I saw a two-digit decrease in percentage points in my portfolio.
Interestingly, I am undeterred and nowhere close to suffering from loss aversion just yet. As I read back the blog posts to remind myself of the reasons why I chose to stay invested, it is still relevant and the fundamentals of CDG has not changed up to this point of time. Therefore, it is most likely that I would stay vested for some time.
I have also mentioned before that I would cheer and accumulate more shares in the event that CDG share prices decline. Unfortunately, I can’t cheer just yet, and I should elaborate why.
With the current situation, I have two options.
- Stay with my holdings at $2.33 and continue to collect a decent dividend yield of 4.42% to 4.46% as calculated using 2016’s and 2017’s dividend yield respectively, which I was initially satisfied with and why I bought it at $2.33 in the first place.
- Wait for the price to drop even lower and average down to a target price of $2.05 and a dividend yield of 5%.
Option 2 is actually not that difficult to achieve with the current price, and I have done my calculations for it. However, I need it to come down to a range of $1.9x and below before I would be willing to average down. Otherwise, I would continue with Option 1 and adopt buy-and-hold. I don’t need the money now anyway and I have sufficient funds for other potential investments.
You might be reading this and going bananas especially if you are in the same situation as me, because now, I only wish that the price would go much lower. “Are you crazy, Miss Niao?! Better cut your loss before you lose everything!”
If anything, I think right now, there is more upside for me when the price declines. I stand strong with me being able to sustain from any pain if I should see it drop even to 50%, and this is also something which I’ve mentioned before. By then, I think I would cheer even louder, unless of course if I do see a valid change in their annual reports and fundamentals. Till then, Option 1’s the way to go!
More ComfortDelgro related posts here.
Thanks for reading!
Miss Niao xoxo
Hmmm probably will see further weakness in the share price over medium term (no real catalyst to solve their main taxi biz) …. although may have a short-term bounce soon (oversold)…
That’s the problem with investing in individual stocks — you take on unsystematic risk i.e. company risk.
Which of course theory will say you minimize by not having >5% of your portfolio in any 1 company…
Unless you eat, sleep, breathe the company inside out, & you know their businesses & plans better than your own face …. then maybe can take more concentrated bet!! 🙂
Personally I’m too lazy & weak of heart to handle the hard work & excitement of individual stocks investing … hence mostly ETFs for me (London, HK & some US — those on SGX mostly too illiquid for me).
The only companies I own on SGX are 2 of the local banks … and even then I bought during recessions, so that I can basically just buy & forget — if they collapse it means S’pore also collapse.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I believe ETFs are good enough to get vested already. 😉
Everyone has their own risk tolerance and what they can accept. You are right to say that I am taking more risk, but I would argue that it isn’t uncalculated. :p
Just buy and hold, like forever, and buy more when the next recession comes! 🙂
LikeLike
Well, I am in the same ship as you. It is painful to watch how it spiralled down rapidly in the last 2 weeks. I reckon it that it will drop further … the sentiment around is really bad. I will try to get some now and more later if I can afford 😁
LikeLiked by 1 person
Certainly, I know how you feel about the pain, because I was actually quite anxious when it declined a hell lot (like 7% within a day). And because it’s my first time experiencing this so I didn’t really know how to deal with it.
As blogged, I think we should be more positive about the current situation actually. 🙂
And I thought you got out already! :p
LikeLiked by 1 person
No worries. Get dividend while waiting, same boat at 2.27
LikeLiked by 1 person
Hi missniao,
S&P500 suffered the following single day losses during the great financial crisis.
2008-09-15 -4.71%
2008-09-17 -4.71%
2008-09-29 -8.81%
2008-10-07 -5.74%
2008-10-09 -7.62%
2008-10-15 -9.03%
2008-10-22 -6.10%
2008-11-20 -6.71%
2008-12-01 -8.93%
Single stocks could have fallen 2-10 times more than S&P500.
If you are worried, with just a single stock falling double digits %, you won’t be able to handle an entire portfolio that fall by double digits %.
Cheers!
Matthew
LikeLike
Not worried anymore! 🙂 Ironically I am actually more worried that it doesn’t fall any further lol
LikeLike
http://singaporeanstocksinvestor.blogspot.sg/2017/09/technical-analysis-of-comfortdelgro.html
LikeLiked by 1 person
Hahahahhaa Matthew… I tried reading it but I understand nuts because I have no knowledge about TA. :p Only thing I could conclude from the article was that there is a high probability that the prices will tumble further.
So maybe you are trying to tell me without words not to worry! :p
LikeLike